Arab-Americans need a box on the US Census Form!
Join the Facebook Page
Follow Amer Zahr

amer@amerzahr.com
America's Funniest
(& Smartest) Arab

This Arab is voting for the Jew
Amer Zahr
by Amer Zahr
February 22nd, 2016 (7 Comments)
Share on Facebook2.2kTweet about this on Twitter32Share on LinkedIn4Share on Google+0Email this to someone

Many of us read Professor Steven Salaita's hard-hitting oped in Salon ten days ago, where he declared, quite loudly and articulately, that he won't be voting for Bernie Sanders. He succinctly laid out American politicians' long-standing and very consistent policies of bowing to the interests of the Israeli lobby, to the constant detriment of Palestinian life.  He wrote:

Supporting Israeli ethnic cleansing is more than a flaw or an oversight. Until Sanders states an intention to defund Israel’s occupation, his proclamations about two states will continue to sound perfunctory and disingenuous, dull bromides uttered by a man who otherwise avoids them.

He is no doubt right about this. The problem with his analysis is that it relegates Palestine supporters to the sideline.  If one chooses to do, that is of course his/her right.  Inherent in the right to vote is the right not to vote.  I'm not a proponent of the old mantra that tell us, "If you don't vote, you have no right to complain."

But we might be served to think strategically.  And if we do so, we might ask ourselves a few questions:

Can we relate Palestine to a candidate's stated principles?
Which candidate is most likely to be swayed on Palestinian rights?
Where do we find our natural allies? In other words, which candidate's followers' political leanings and worldviews most resemble our own?

If we seek the answers to these questions, we most definitely end up in once place: the Sanders campaign.

What seems quite clear is that Palestine supporters can find no place anywhere else.  We can quite quickly dismiss a role in any Republican campaign, as they are all mired in Islamphobia, anti-Arab racism, a quite acute hatred of immigrants, and clear distaste for anything darker than snow.  This is why we should summarily disregard any and all organizations that seek dialogue and understanding with the GOP, such as Saba Ahmed's Republican Muslim Coalition.

We might take a quick look at the campaign Hillary Clinton, gauging if her movement should appeal to us at all.  But that assessment shouldn't take too long.  We would be well served to recall her 2000 Senate election, when she returned over $50,000 of donations to Muslim organizations, in an attempt to avoid any "misimpression" that she supported the widely held belief in our community that Palestinians have the right to resist an illegal, violent, and murderous Israeli occupation.

It would also be quite within our interests to reject her embracing of Haim Saban, the Hollywood billionaire media mogul who has been quoted as saying, "I'm a one-issue guy and my issue is Israel."  He is very close friend of the Clintons (he brags about it often), spending numerous nights in the White House during Bill Clinton's presidency.  I wish some Palestinians could have spent the night there, instead of being slaughtered in Gaza in 2014, after which Saban held an event that raised $34 million for the IDF.

Hillary Clinton has vowed to put an end to the Boycott, Divesment, and Sanctions movement against Israel, or BDS.  In a letter to Saban, she pledged to "stand up for Israel" as president, further stating "that we need to make countering BDS a priority."  In other words, Clinton has made it quite clear that she opposes all forms of resistance against Israeli policies, including explicitly nonviolent ones like BDS.

All in all, Saban has "donated" $6.4 million to Hillary and her super PACs.

So, back to Bernie.  Has he recently advocated for defunding Israel, called for cutting off arms, or explicitly expressed support for Palestinian self-determination? No.  But he doesn't done the opposite, as every other candidate has.  Now, Professor Salaita might call that a low bar, and he would be correct.  But we should also recognize that the spectrum of progressives who are supporting the Sanders campaign are generally averse to Israeli policies, and it is not immoral or unprincipled to find some common ground there in our attempt to further American policy on the issue.

On his website, Sanders proclaims that "he does not favor Israel over the Palestinians."  No other candidate would dare put such words in print.  And on the issue of Palestine, Sanders' Jewishness cannot be understated.  Until we get a Palestinian president, a progressive Jew might be best equipped to stand up to the Israeli lobby and create just foreign policies when it comes to Palestine. Is that a pipe dream? Maybe. But if we Palestinians have an abundance of anything, it's optimism.

Finally, Bernie has spoken out more strongly against Islamophobia and racism than any other candidate.  We are all familiar with his well-documented participation in civil rights movements since the 1960s.  But we might also remember back in October 2015 when Sanders embraced a young Muslim student during a rally at George Mason University in Virginia.  After expressing her disgust at the anti-Muslim rhetoric dominating the presidential primaries, Remaz Abdelgader was called on to the stage by Sanders, who hugged her and went on to invoke his own Jewish familial history in pledging to rid America of its "ugly stain" of racism.

A quick note here for Senator Sanders.  Bernie, in the picture above, we all noticed that you were holding Ramez's hand.  In our culture, that means you have to marry her.  But go win the election first.  While her parents most likely won't let her marry a Jew, if he's the president, that might change their minds.

Ultimately, if any Arab or Muslim American does have the inclination to vote in the American election, he or she cannot land anywhere except in Bernie's camp.  While Sanders doesn't explicitly say what he want him to on Palestine, when I look around during his rallies, I see a sea of faces that do.  And if they can say "Free Palestine," I can legitimately work to make Bernie say it too.  With a strong Arab American voice, I can quite comfortably proclaim that I #FeelTheBern.

 

Share on Facebook2.2kTweet about this on Twitter32Share on LinkedIn4Share on Google+0Email this to someone
*

Amer Zahr is a Palestinian American comedian, writer, professor and speaker living in Dearborn, Michigan. He is also the editor of “The Civil Arab.”

Comments (7)
  1. Halina Minadeo ... February 23rd, 2016 - 05:53

    I just love that photo of Bernie holding the pretty young lady’s hand. He is a sweet old Jewish bubba. His father came from Poland, where I was born in 1943, although I am 100% Ukrainian, so that is a plus in his favour. Here’s hoping that we have a chance to vote for the man!

  2. Richard Reilly ... February 23rd, 2016 - 12:13

    This Irish-American hopes that Sanders earlier solidarity with Bobby Sands and the Irish hunger strikers in 1981 is extended to Palestinian journalist Mohammed al-Queeq, now on his 91st day of hunger strike and near death: https://www.change.org/p/bernie-sanders-demand-that-israel-free-mohammed-al-qeeq

  3. I love your column, Amer! And I already voted for Bernie, partially for the reasons you name – at least he hasn’t pledged allegiance to giving Israel endless billions, as everyone else does – thank you for bringing light and good humor to our thinking!

  4. Nice post.

    Prof. Salaita is the guy who said that he sees no difference between Norman Finkelstein, someone who, regardless of what you and I might think of his stand on BDS, has given the better part of his life to standing up for the Palestinians, and Netanyahu (the less said about him the better). I think that ends the conversation right there.

    But on the American political spectrum, his position is much more progressive than the run of the AIPAC tools we have running.

    Voting for him gives us a chance to start a dialogue with him; I think you’ll find a willing ear. You’re against new settlements? What about the old settlements? What would the boundaries of a Palestinian state be in rough terms? What about the status of Jerusalem? Of East Jerusalem? How about working right here and now with human rights groups like B’Tselem which are under attack by the Israeli government, led by the fascist-like rabble of Im Tirtsu?

    Anyway, I love your blog. If you’re ever in Brooklyn, stop by!

  5. Strange that out of all the candidates, the only Jew is the one most supportive of Palestine. Go Bernie.

  6. Donna M. Joss ... March 9th, 2016 - 10:19

    Amer, just found this column and love it! I’m a Scottish/Irish/American and have resistance-to-occupation blood running in my veins. Guess that’s why I’ve been a supporter of Palestine for close to 30 years. So I’m voting for Sanders for many of the reasons you list. Basically, I trust him to, as nearly as possible, do the right thing for Palestine when he is elected.
    BTW, where was the Arab vote in the Michigan primary last night? Subsumed in the ‘white’ category?

  7. Avram Davis ... March 13th, 2016 - 19:36

    /Users/avramdavis/Desktop/iu.png Most Arabs living in the Homeland of the Jewish People have been there a hundred years or less. This gives them standing, but not a veto and certainly not a right to colonize our ancestral home. If the arabs living within the homeland (similarly to non Kurds living inside Kurdistan), wish to be good citizens, pay their taxes, serve in the forces and be peaceful, then they will be integrated completely into the country and economy. As have the Druze, Bedouin, Circassians and increasing numbers of Christian arabs. If the arabs living in our Homeland embrace only violence and seeking a civil war, then they will have to leave.


Leave a comment

Trackbacks are disabled.

Archive